Customer Service

As an independent insurance agent, we don’t work for an insurance company, instead, Pagel Insurance and Associates represent a number of different companies, and works for you, to help you choose the insurance company that is best for your particular situation.

When it comes to service, the same holds true. We work for you. Helping you with whatever it may be including questions about your billing, changes to your policy, or in the event that you have a loss, we are there to help.

The following is a list of the companies we represent along with their website addresses and phone numbers should you have to contact them directly.

AAA

AAA Address 8401 Excelsior Boulevard Madison WI 53717 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-236-1300home Billing: 800-677-0777homefax Claims: 800-723-0220cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Acuity

Acuity Address 2800 South Taylor Drive PO Box 58 Sheboygan WI 53082-0058 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 920-458-9131home Billing: 800-242-7666homefax Claims: 800-242-7666cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

American Collectors

American Collectors Address P.O. Box 8343 Cherry Hill NJ 08002-0343 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-360-2277home Website Billing Website Claims Website

American Modern

American Modern Address P.O. Box 5323 Cincinnati OH 45201 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-543-2644home Billing: 800-543-2644homefax Claims: 800-375-2075cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Badger Mutual Insurance Company

Badger Mutual Insurance Company Address 1635 West National Avenue Milwaukee WI 53204 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-837-7833home Billing: 800-837-7833homefax Claims: 800-837-7833cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Bristol West (now Foremost Insurance Group)

Bristol West (now Foremost Insurance Group) Address P.O. Box 371329  Pittsburgh PA 15250-7329 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 888-888-0080home Billing: 888-888-0080homefax Claims: 800-274-7865cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Condon Skelly

Condon Skelly Address 1 Executive Drive, Suite 5 Moorestown NJ 8057 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-257–9496home Website

Continental Western Group

Continental Western Group Address PO Box 1594 Des Moines IA 50306-1594 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 877-643-0219home Billing: 877-385-9114homefax Claims: 515-473-3392cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Dairyland

Dairyland Address PO Box 8021 Stevens Point WI 54481-8021 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-334-0090home Website Billing Website Claims Website

Foremost

Foremost Address PO Box 0915 Carol Stream IL 60132-0915 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-527-3905home Billing: 800-435-7764homefax Claims: 800-527-3907cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Founders Insurance Company

Founders Insurance Company Address 1350 E Touhy Ave Suite 200W Des Plaines IL 60018 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 847-768-0040home Billing: 847-768-0040homefax Claims: 888-676-4342cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

GEICO

GEICO Address 4608 Willard Ave Chevy Chase MD 20815 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-207-7847home Billing: 800-932-8872homefax Claims: 800-841-3000cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Hagerty

Hagerty Address P.O. Box 1303 Traverse City MI 49685-1303 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 877-922-9701home Billing: 888-220-9565homefax Website Billing Website Claims Website

Integrity Insurance

Integrity Insurance Address 2121 East Capitol Drive PO Box 539 Appleton WI 54912-0539 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 866-550-9220home Billing: 888-699-9182homefax Claims: 800-445-3030cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Main Street America

Main Street America Address 15490 101st Avenue North Maple Grove MN 55369 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-328-4628home Billing: 888-333-4014homefax Claims: 877-425-2467cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Maple Valley Mutual

Maple Valley Mutual Address 304 N Rosera Street PO Box 59 Lena WI 54139 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 920-829-5525home Billing: 920-829-5525homefax Claims: 920-829-5525cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

McMillian Warner Mutual

McMillian Warner Mutual Address 2510 N Central Ave P.O. Box 429 Marshfield WI 54449 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 715-387-8454home Website Billing Website Claims Website

Mutual of Wausau

Mutual of Wausau Address 3910 West Stewart Ave PO Box 269 Wausau WI 54402-0269 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 855-393-4600home Website Billing Website Claims Website

Nationwide

Nationwide Address PO Box 742522 Cincinnati OH 45274-2522 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 877-669-6877home Billing: 877-262-0247homefax Claims: 800-421-3535cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Progressive

Progressive Address 6300 Wilson Mills Rd Mayfield Village OH 44143 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 888-671-4405home Billing: 888-671-4405homefax Claims: 800-776-4737cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Safeco Insurance

Safeco Insurance Address P.O. Box 6476 Carol Stream IL 60197 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-332-3226home Billing: 888-723-3260homefax Claims: 800-332-3226cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Secura

Secura Address 2401 South Memorial Drive PO Box 819 Appleton WI 54912-0819 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-558-3405home Billing: 800-830-9150homefax Claims: 800-318-2136cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Selective

Selective Address 11711 North Meridian Street Suite 800 Carmel IN 46032 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 866-248-0850home Billing: 888-974-7400homefax Claims: 866-455-9969cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

State Auto Insurance Companies

State Auto Insurance Companies Address 518 East Broad St Columbus OH 43215 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-492-5246home Billing: 800-444-9950 x5118homefax Claims: 800-766-1853cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

The General Insurance

The General Insurance Address 2636 Elm Hill Pike Suite 510 Nashville TN 37214 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 866-519-7422home Claims: 800-280-1466cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

The Hartford

The Hartford Address One Hartford Plaza Hartford CT 6155 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-624-5578home Billing: 800-423-6789homefax Claims: 800-243-5860cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Travelers – Personal Lines

Travelers – Personal Lines Address PO Box 660307 Dallas TX 75266-0307 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 866-336-2077home Billing: 800-842-5075homefax Claims: 800-252-4633cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

United Mutual Insurance

United Mutual Insurance Address 141 South Wisconsin Ave PO Box 406 Medford WI 54451 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-236-2682home Billing: 800-236-2682homefax Website Billing Website Claims Website

West Bend

West Bend Address 1900 S 18th Ave West Bend WI 53095 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-236-5010home Claims: 877-922-5246cell Website Billing Website Claims Website

Western National

Western National Address 5350 West 78th Street Edina MN 55439 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-862–6070home Website Billing Website Claims Website

Wisconsin Mutual Insurance Company

Wisconsin Mutual Insurance Company Address 8201 Excelsior Dr Madison WI 53717 United Stateshome General Inquiries: 800-831-5959home Billing: 800-831-5959homefax Claims: 800-831-5959cell Website Billing Website Claims Website